Utah Shared Access Alliance

Tools

Sen. Hillyard weighs in on bill critical of 17th Amendment

By BROCK VERGAKIS Associated Press Writer

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) -- Lawmakers from the only state that rejected a constitutional amendment allowing for the direct election of U.S. senators are still looking for ways to influence who represents the state - nearly a century after the 17th Amendment was passed.

The Utah Senate approved a bill Monday clarifying that political parties can seek the opinion of state lawmakers when choosing their nominees for U.S Senate.

The idea is that the 3,500 delegates who choose nominees in heavily Republican Utah would pay close attention to what the Legislature thinks of incumbents' records on states rights - a hot topic issue among conservatives here.

Senate Bill 250 is sponsored by Sen. Howard Stephenson, a Draper Republican who contends the 17th Amendment was a mistake. Before the amendment's ratification in 1913, state legislatures were responsible for electing U.S. senators.

Stephenson has said he favors a repeal of the 17th Amendment but acknowledges that would be too difficult.

"I believe this would enhance the attention our U.S. senators give to the state and to the state legislature," Stephenson said.

Since 2006, Stephenson has been trying to find a way to give state lawmakers more influence in Washington.

Past efforts would have allowed the Legislature to provide direction to the state's U.S. senators and require them to provide periodic reports to state lawmakers on how they're complying with that direction. U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, scoffed at that notion when he visited in 2007 to address the Legislature as he does every year.

"I'd be happy to have direction, happy to have counsel, happy to have input," he said. "But I don't think you need the Legislature to do all that."

Stephenson's bill passed Monday 20-8, largely along party lines.

Sen. Lyle Hillyard, R-Logan, said he didn't think Stephenson's bill was a bad idea, just that it was unnecessary.

Indeed, the chairmen of the Utah Republican and Democratic parties both said there's nothing to stop parties from consulting legislators already.

"We could do that right now without the bill," said GOP Chairman Dave Hansen. "It's one of those issues I rarely, if ever, hear about. ... It certainly does not rank with health care as an issue. There's a lot of other things delegates are more concerned with right now."

Utah Democratic Party Chairman Wayne Holland said his party already gets input from its legislators, but Democrats have no desire to institute a formal process to get their blessing when choosing nominees.

"There's no doubt in my mind what (Sen. Stephenson) would have us do is polarize this country more than it already is, to have U.S. senators beholden to state legislative leaders - especially in states where leadership tends to be very partisan and very ideological," Holland said. "That would be just a disaster to our country."

SB250 now advances to the House. The legislative session ends Thursday.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Anonymous said on Friday, Mar 12 at 5:08 PM

For anyone with an understanding about the flow of powers intended by the Constitution, it is clear that the 17th Amendment pretty much demolished federalism and dual sovereignty - topics both Hamilton and Madison were pretty passionate about in several of the Federalist Papers. So you can criticize the legislator for whatever reason, but an effort to restore a true balance of power will be understood by those who are studied in the area. Perhaps a different method would be more effective, but I applaud any effort to fix this tremendous problem. States need a place at the table in DC. Pre-17th they had it. Post-17th it is lost. Of course Hatch doesn't like the idea. What U.S. Senator would want more accountability and less power?

39154413
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

CVCA said on Monday, Mar 8 at 9:42 PM

Have all the republican members of the state legislature lost their minds or has there been a rush to see which one can out due chris buttars to become utahs number one idiot?? Lyle always manages to keep himself in the race.

38904196
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tom Grover said on Monday, Mar 8 at 5:34 PM

Utah conservatives pound their fists and demand respect for the Constitution.... except for when they don't respect the Constitution.

38893864
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Cache Valley Daily and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.