ATLANTA (AP) — Georgia’s highest court tossed out a gag order in the high-profile case of a slain high school teacher and former beauty pageant contestant whose mysterious disappearance more than 12 years ago drew “significant media interest.”
Tara Grinstead was reported missing in October 2005 when she didn’t show up for work at a school in rural Irwin County. The case went cold until new information led to the arrest in February 2017 of Ryan Alexander Duke, a former student at the school where Grinstead taught.
But authorities have been tightlipped about what led to the arrest and any motive behind the slaying, and the judge overseeing the case issued a gag order.
Duke burglarized the teacher’s home in Ocilla, about 190 miles (305 kilometers) south of Atlanta, and used his hands to kill her inside the residence, according to warrants that were read at a court hearing when his arrest was announced. He removed her body from the home with the intent of concealing her death, the warrants said.
Soon after Duke’s arrest, the judge overseeing the case issued a gag order prohibiting attorneys, investigators, potential witnesses and even relatives of the victim and suspects from publicly discussing Grinstead’s slaying. The judge later modified it to prohibit attorneys, law enforcement and court personnel from disclosing case evidence, any statements made by Duke, expected witness testimony and potential pleas.
Duke was indicted in April on two counts of felony murder and one count each of malice murder, aggravated assault, burglary and concealing the death of another.
A second man, Bo Dukes, was indicted in June on charges of concealing a death, tampering with evidence and hindering the apprehension of a criminal.
WXIA-TV and WMAZ-TV challenged the amended gag order and the Georgia Supreme Court heard arguments in the case in October.
“A gag order like this one may be constitutionally permissible in exceptional circumstances, but the record here does not reveal circumstances sufficiently exceptional to warrant such a restraint,” Justice Keith Blackwell wrote in a unanimous opinion. “For that reason, we vacate the gag order.”
The high court acknowledged the “significant media interest” in the case but found no inflammatory or prejudicial statements attributed to anyone covered by the gag order that would be likely to prejudice Duke’s right to a trial by an impartial jury. Many of the details in news reports were drawn from arrest warrants and other public records, the court noted. The case was also featured on a popular podcast “Up and Vanished.”
Attorney Derek Bauer, who argued against the gag order, said his clients are happy with the ruling and that it should serve as a guide for future cases.
“We believe the opinion reinforces the importance of the public’s role, through the news media as its proxy, as the nation’s watchdog over the criminal process, and will improve public oversight of the courts in Georgia for decades to come,” he wrote in an email.
Tifton Judicial Circuit District Attorney Paul Bowden, who had argued in favor of the gag order, said in an email that the order speaks for itself and declined to comment further.